“I told the designer ‘modern and clean’. Six rounds later I still can’t say why I hate it.”
Walt
A designer gets a brief that says “make it modern and clean” and very little else. The work comes back looking fine, but it doesn’t fit, and nobody can say why. Six rounds of changes later, the budget is gone and the founder still isn’t happy.
The problem usually isn’t the designer. It’s that nobody decided who the customer is, what the business stands for or what makes it different before design started. A logo can’t answer those questions for you. They have to be settled first and written down in a brief.
Refresh or full rebrand?
Before you write anything, decide how big the job is. A refresh is enough when the foundations are right but the look is dated or inconsistent. A full rebrand is needed when the foundations themselves have moved: you serve different customers, sell something different or stand for something new.
Either way, decide what must stay, then change only what has to change.
Decide five things before you brief anyone
1. One primary customer
You should be able to describe your main customer without saying “everyone”. Think about your last ten customers and answer these:
- Who buys from you now, and who do you most enjoy serving?
- What problem were they trying to solve when they found you?
- What had they already tried?
- What nearly stopped them buying?
- Who should you not be serving?
Then collect their exact words from reviews, emails and enquiry forms. The best headlines often come straight from a customer.
2. What you stand for
A brand is what people come to expect from you, and that comes from how you behave more than how you look. Your values should come from your history, not a list of nice words. Test each one against a real decision you’ve made. If it never changed a decision, it isn’t a value.
3. One sentence of positioning
Use this formula: we help [one specific customer] [achieve one specific outcome] by [what we do differently], and you can trust us because [the proof we have].
Read it to someone who fits your customer. If they can’t repeat back who it’s for and what it does, cut words until they can.
4. How you sound
Pick a few words for your tone of voice, and write down what each one means and what it doesn’t. Ours are direct, practical and encouraging without hype. So we’d write “Start with the evidence you already have”, not “Unlock your limitless potential today!”
5. Your never list
Write down what you’ll never say or do: claims you can’t back up, fake urgency, guarantees you can’t control, reviews or results that aren’t real. Give the list to everyone who writes for you, including agencies and AI tools.
What goes in the brief
The brief turns those decisions into one page a designer can work from. It also gives you something to judge the work against. If it isn’t in the brief, the designer has to guess. Cover:
- Who the customer is and the problem you solve
- What you stand for
- Your positioning and key message
- Your tone of voice
- Competitors, and how you need to stand apart
- Where the brand will be used: website, packaging, signage, social
- Non-negotiables and your never list
- Examples you like and don’t like, and why
- Budget and timeline
- Who signs off
That last line matters more than it looks. Work gets watered down when too many people give feedback.
Asking for quotes
Costs range widely, from a basic identity to full strategy, naming and a brand system with a website. Decide what you need first, then ask every designer or agency to quote the same scope so you’re comparing like for like.
Ask how many concepts and rounds of changes are included and which files you’ll receive. Get written confirmation that you’ll own the files and the rights. Timelines depend as much on how quickly you make decisions as on the design work.
Judging what comes back
Expect two or three genuinely different directions, not dozens of variations. Judge each one against the brief, not your favourite colour. Ask:
- Does it suit our customer?
- Does it say what we stand for?
- Does it work small, in one colour and on a phone?
- Does it work on packaging and signage?
- Is it different from our competitors?
- Have people who fit our customer seen it, not just friends and family?
When you give feedback, explain the problem, not the solution. Say “this feels too corporate for our customer”, not “make it blue”. Link every point to the brief, say what’s working as well as what isn’t, and send one combined round of feedback from the people who sign off.
Before you sign off
Make sure you receive master logo files in every version (full colour, one colour and reversed), files for print and screen, colour codes, font files or licences, a brand guide and templates for what you use most. Get written confirmation that you own all of it.
Then roll the new brand out in order of what customers see most. Website, Google Business Profile, social profiles and email signatures come first. Proposals, quotes and invoices come second. Packaging, signage and printed material come last.
Start with one sentence
Write one sentence that says who you help, what you help them do and why it matters. If you can’t, that’s the work to do before you hire a designer.

